The 3D Conversion Paradox

There is a certain irony in the world of 2D-to-3D film conversion. The most challenging projects to work on are also those with the smallest potential audience, while some of the most commercially attractive opportunities could actually be considerably easier to deliver.
At EYEPOP-3D, much of our work has involved converting public domain films, many of which are several decades old. It is a fascinating area to work in, not least because of the opportunity to introduce classic cinema to a new generation of 3D enthusiasts. However, from a purely technical and commercial perspective, it presents some rather interesting contradictions.

Old films are not necessarily easy films to convert

It might be tempting to assume that converting an older black-and-white film into 3D is a relatively straightforward exercise. After all, there are no complicated modern visual effects, fast-moving action sequences or elaborate digital environments to contend with.
The reality is often quite the opposite.
Older films can present some particularly difficult challenges for modern conversion workflows, especially those that rely on AI-assisted depth map generation.
Film grain, image noise, scratches, dirt, physical film damage, inconsistent exposure and poor definition can all interfere with the process. Add to this the limitations of the original cinematography and the general lack of fine image detail, and you have a source that can be considerably more difficult for AI tools to interpret accurately.
Depth map generation relies on identifying objects, surfaces, edges and spatial relationships within an image. When those details are obscured by grain, damage or simply weren't captured particularly clearly in the first place, the results can become unpredictable.
An AI-generated depth map might interpret a patch of film damage as an object, mistake background texture for foreground detail or fail to distinguish between two elements that should occupy different depth planes.
This means considerably more manual intervention is often required. Depth maps need correcting, refining and sculpting, with individual shots requiring careful attention to achieve a convincing stereoscopic result.
In other words, the age of the source material can make what initially appears to be a simple conversion anything but simple.
The paradoxical effect of having more time to look

There is another, perhaps less obvious, challenge with older films: their pacing.
Classic cinema frequently features longer, more lingering shots. Scenes are allowed to breathe, dialogue sequences can remain relatively static, and the camera may hold on a composition for considerably longer than would be typical in much modern filmmaking.
From a stereoscopic conversion perspective, this creates an interesting paradox.
The longer a shot remains on screen, the more opportunity the viewer has to examine the image in three dimensions which is perfect from a viewing perspective. They can look around the composition, appreciate the depth relationships and, unfortunately, this means the viewer notices the little things that might otherwise go unnoticed, so attention to detail is paramount when converting.
A minor inconsistency in depth, a slightly imperfect edge or an object that doesn't sit quite naturally within the scene can become much more apparent when the viewer has several seconds to study it.
Modern films, by comparison, often employ much shorter shots and faster editing. A conversion imperfection that might be noticeable during a long, static dialogue scene could pass almost entirely unnoticed during a brief, fast-moving shot.
This isn't to suggest that modern films are inherently easier in every respect. Fast action, complex visual effects, transparency, motion blur and intricate compositing can all introduce their own difficulties. However, the combination of better source quality and shorter shot durations can make many modern productions considerably more straightforward to process and refine.
Modern films: Better sources, better opportunities

The contrast becomes particularly interesting when we consider the quality of modern source material.
Modern films are generally captured and finished at much higher resolutions, with considerably greater image clarity and detail. Edges are cleaner, textures are more defined and objects are generally easier to distinguish.
This makes a significant difference.
Depth maps can often be generated more quickly and accurately, with fewer errors requiring manual correction. There is still artistic judgement involved in sculpting convincing stereoscopic depth, but the technical starting point is often much better.
Rather than spending valuable production time correcting problems caused by the limitations of the original film, more time can be devoted to the creative aspects of the conversion: establishing depth relationships, shaping the stereoscopic experience and ensuring that the finished result complements the original cinematography.
In many cases, modern productions simply provide a much better foundation on which to build a high-quality 3D conversion.
And then there is the audience size

Perhaps the biggest irony, however, is commercial.
Older public domain films, particularly black-and-white titles, naturally appeal to a niche audience, when converted to 3D even more so. There is certainly a dedicated community of classic film enthusiasts and 3D collectors, but the potential market for a 1930s or 1940s film converted into 3D is inevitably limited.
This is not necessarily a criticism. These films have their own appeal, and there is genuine satisfaction in bringing something unexpected to the 3D format. But it does create an imbalance between the amount of work involved and the potential return.
A modern blockbuster, on the other hand, presents a very different proposition.
Imagine a popular catalogue title with an established fanbase, recognisable cast and existing commercial appeal. A high-quality 3D conversion could potentially attract not only existing 3D enthusiasts but also fans of the original film who would be interested in experiencing it in a new format.
The 3D Blu-ray market may be relatively small compared with the mainstream home entertainment market, but that doesn't mean there isn't a viable opportunity.
In fact, a carefully selected modern catalogue title could make a very compelling premium physical media release.
The theatrical opportunity changes the economics

There is another important consideration: theatrical distribution.
One of the biggest obstacles to producing a genuinely high-quality 3D conversion is the investment required. A proper conversion, even using the most cost effective approach, requires some level of investment, particularly when the objective is to achieve the level of quality expected for a theatrical release.
However, that investment doesn't necessarily need to be recovered from a single distribution channel.
A theatrical 3D re-release, supported by subsequent 3D Blu-ray and potentially digital or immersive headset distribution, creates the opportunity to spread the conversion investment across several revenue streams.
The theatrical release provides an opportunity to reach a wider audience and generate additional revenue, while the physical media release offers a premium product for collectors and home cinema enthusiasts.
The same conversion can also potentially support emerging distribution opportunities in VR and AR environments, where interest in high-quality stereoscopic entertainment continues to develop.
Rather than viewing 3D Blu-ray as an isolated product with a limited audience, it makes more sense to consider it as one component of a broader 3D distribution strategy.
A theatrical re-release could help justify the initial investment, making the subsequent Blu-ray release a much more attractive commercial proposition.
So why do we keep converting the old films?

This brings us back to the original irony. The costs to legally license, commercially convert and globally distribute larger commercial films limits the level and scale of business who could undertake these projects. This leaves us with the public domain niche.
So whilst there is something rewarding about taking an old film, with all the imperfections of its original source, and giving it an entirely new dimension, it's not necessarily a financial reward.
The real opportunity for the future of 3D conversion then isn't simply finding more films to convert, but finding the right films to convert that a large enough audience is interested in seeing.
And that means looking beyond the public domain catalogue.
For film rights holders, producers and distributors sitting on valuable back catalogues, there may be an opportunity here that is worth exploring.
The question isn't necessarily whether a film can be converted into 3D. Increasingly, the question should be whether there is a commercial reason to do so.

If you have a catalogue title that you believe could benefit from a 3D release, EYEPOP-3D would be interested in discussing the possibilities. From initial source assessment through to full stereoscopic conversion and delivery for theatrical, physical media and immersive platforms, we offer a specialist, cost-effective approach to bringing existing films into 3D.
Your 2D to 3D Conversion Partner.





As an avid 3D fan , please keep up the good work. My Eyepop collection is growing. In fact it may be brought up to date by Christmas . I will be asking my two daughters to combine & buy me the last seven blu ray 3D discs I need . ( hopefully)